Cache Valley virus (CVV), a mosquito-borne orthobunyavirus, causes epizootics in ruminants characterized by congenital malformations and fetal death in North America. Only seven human infections have been identified; limited information exists on its potential as a human teratogen. Diagnosis of CVV infections relies on the plaque reduction neutralization test (PRNT), which requires live virus, is time-consuming, and cannot differentiate between recent and past infections. To improve diagnostics for CVV, we developed an IgM antibody capture ELISA (MAC-ELISA) for detection of anti-CVV human IgM in diagnostic specimens that can be performed faster than PRNT and is specific to IgM, which is essential to determine the timing of infection. Conjointly, a cell line constitutively expressing human-murine chimeric antibody with the variable regions of monoclonal antibody CVV-17 and constant regions of human IgM was developed to provide positive control material. The new cell line produced antibody with reactivity in the assay equivalent to that of a human serum sample positive for anti-CVV IgM. Five of seven archived human specimens diagnostically confirmed as CVV positive tested positive in the MAC-ELISA, whereas 44 specimens confirmed positive for another arboviral infection tested negative, showing good initial correlation of the CVV MAC-ELISA. Two of 27 previously collected serum samples from febrile patients in Yucatán, Mexico, who tested negative for a recent flaviviral or alphaviral infection were positive in both the MAC-ELISA and PRNT, indicating a possible recent infection with CVV or related orthobunyavirus. The MAC-ELISA described here will aid in making diagnostics more widely available for CVV in public health laboratories.